RSS Feed

The Uprising: A Missed Opportunity

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

I didn't watch The Uprising when it was in theaters in September. It was a movie I wanted to see, but real life interrupted my movie-viewing plans. Again.

Having not seen the movie, I was caught off guard when a friend asked me, "Why does The Uprising blow chunks?"

I finally watched it over the weekend on Peacock. I don't think the movie blows chunks, but it isn't very good either. So, the obvious question is: Why?

As a history major, people sometimes assume I know the background of whatever historical epic they're discussing and understand exactly what's supposed to be going on. Unfortunately, the Peasants' Revolt of 1381 is an era of English history I know relatively little about. I can tell you it happened in 1381, but beyond that, you're not going to get much from me without opening a book.

That said, after watching the movie, I did a little reading. And that made me even more disappointed with what the filmmakers produced.

In many ways, The Uprising was set up for success. It has a strong cast, an abundance of extras, and a historical period that hasn't been overproduced in film and television. The Peasants' Revolt is a fascinating subject, and its themes of economic inequality, political power, taxation, and social unrest certainly resonate with contemporary audiences.

The filmmakers had plenty to work with.

Unfortunately, being set up for success doesn't mean you can execute the project successfully. And that's what happens here.

You can have a great cast, but if the story is incomplete, the cinematography is distracting, and the sound is uninspired, you have a problem. A movie needs more than recognizable actors and a collection of impressive-looking battle scenes.

The Story That Wasn't Told

The biggest problem with The Uprising is the story itself.

It isn't complete. More importantly, it doesn't seem to know whether it wants to tell the actual historical story or create a new mythology around it. It attempts to blend the two and doesn't do either particularly well.

The Peasants' Revolt wasn't simply a spontaneous uprising of impoverished people who decided they had enough of the ruling class.

England was still recovering from the Black Death. The enormous loss of life had changed the labor market, and ordinary workers were in a position to demand better wages and conditions. The government and landowners responded with restrictions on wages and workers' freedom to move. Then came the poll taxes, including the particularly unpopular tax of 1381.

There was a great deal going on beneath the surface.

And then there was the king.

Richard II was only fourteen years old when the revolt occurred. Think about that for a moment. A teenage king suddenly confronted with an enormous rebellion, surrounded by powerful advisers, and expected to maintain control of a kingdom experiencing serious social and economic upheaval.

That's a story.

The rebels weren't necessarily trying to abolish the monarchy. Many believed the king was being misled by corrupt advisers and officials. They wanted their grievances heard, and some believed Richard himself might be sympathetic to their cause.

Why isn't more of this explored?

The film needed someone to sit down with the script and ask a fairly simple question: Why are these characters doing what they're doing?

What motivates them? What do they want? What are they afraid of? What are they willing to sacrifice?

Too often, the characters simply do things because the screenplay requires them to. Their motivations are either poorly explained or never developed. I found myself wondering why certain characters made particular decisions, and a little historical reading afterward only made me wonder why the filmmakers hadn't included some of that background.

The actual history offers plenty of dramatic possibilities. You shouldn't have to invent motivations for historical figures when their real circumstances are already interesting.

The Robin Hood Problem

The other issue is the film's apparent desire to connect the events of 1381 with the Robin Hood legend.

I understand the temptation. Robin Hood is a familiar figure, and the idea of connecting a popular legend to an actual historical rebellion probably sounds attractive to a screenwriter.

But there is a problem.

The Robin Hood tradition is generally associated with an earlier period, often the reign of Richard I, and references to Robin Hood existed before the Peasants' Revolt.

In other words, the filmmakers are trying to create an origin story for a legend that was already circulating.

Why?

The events of 1381 don't need Robin Hood to make them interesting. The actual revolt, its leaders, the young king, and the eventual suppression of the rebellion provide more than enough material.

This is where the movie seems caught between history and mythology. It wants the credibility of a historical epic but also wants to create a heroic legend. The two approaches don't necessarily have to conflict, but the filmmakers never quite make them work together.

The Shaky Camera

The next disturbing problem is the extensive use of the shaky-handheld-camera technique.

If you want to see a good execution of this method, watch Saving Private Ryan. If you want to see a bad execution, The Uprising is a perfect choice.

Handheld cinematography can be extremely effective. It can put the audience in the middle of a battle, create confusion, and make events feel immediate and chaotic.

But there is a time and place for it.

Why are we using a shaky camera during scenes involving the king's council? What exactly are the filmmakers trying to accomplish other than giving a portion of the audience motion sickness?

A technique that works in a battle scene doesn't automatically work in a conversation. Cinematography should serve the story, not become a distraction from it.

There are moments when I wanted the camera to simply stop moving so I could concentrate on what the characters were saying.

That's not a good sign.

Everything Is Dull and Dirty

Then there is the overall appearance of the movie.

Everything is dull and dirty. The landscapes, the costumes, the people, and the characters all seem to exist in a world without much color.

Apparently, historical realism means everything has to be brown, gray, muddy, and miserable.

As a historian, I can tell you that grass was still green and the sky was still blue in 1381. I don't need a history book to tell me that.

Medieval people wore colored clothing. They dyed fabrics, decorated their homes, maintained gardens, and lived in a world that wasn't permanently covered by a gray filter.

Yes, life could be difficult. Yes, there was poverty, disease, and plenty of mud. But the fourteenth century wasn't a monochromatic wasteland.

There is a difference between gritty and realistic.

A muted color palette can be an effective artistic choice, but when everything is muted, the audience loses visual contrast. Eventually, everything starts to look the same.

The filmmakers seem to have confused making a movie look miserable with making it historically authentic.

The Sound Doesn't Help

The sound is another disappointment.

A historical epic needs to create an atmosphere. The sounds of crowds, horses, weapons, and the surrounding environment should help bring the audience into the period.

Instead, the sound design feels rather uninspired. There isn't enough to make the world feel alive, and the overall presentation lacks the impact that a film of this scale should deliver.

It's another example of a production that has the pieces but doesn't seem to know how to put them together.

A Much Better Movie Was Sitting There Waiting to Be Made

What frustrates me most about The Uprising is that the filmmakers had such an interesting historical event available to them.

The Peasants' Revolt of 1381 offers a story about economic change, social class, political power, corruption, and a fourteen-year-old king trying to maintain control of his kingdom.

It is a story about people who believed the system was working against them and who decided to do something about it. It is also a story about how quickly a rebellion can turn into something its original participants may not have intended.

The revolt ultimately failed. Wat Tyler was killed, the king reasserted royal authority, and the government pursued those involved in the rebellion.

There is plenty of drama in that history. There are no shortages of heroes, villains, conflicting motivations, or tragic consequences.

You don't need to manufacture a legend to make it compelling.

And that's really my problem with the movie.

It had a strong cast, an interesting historical setting, plenty of extras, and a subject that could have made for an excellent historical epic. But the screenplay never fully develops its characters or their motivations. The cinematography becomes distracting, the visual presentation is unnecessarily dull, and the sound does little to enhance the experience.

I don't think The Uprising blows chunks.

But it certainly doesn't live up to the opportunity it was given.

Sometimes the most frustrating movies aren't the ones with terrible ideas. They're the ones where you can see the good movie that could have been made, sitting just beneath the surface of the one you actually watched.

maybe Spider-Man: Brand New Day had the wrong Spider-Man

Posted by Jeff

After watching Spider-Man: Brand New Day with my adult children, I was caught off guard by a shared opinion: the movie was good, but it just didn’t quite click.

That caught my attention.

Because apparently it clicked for someone. The movie has an outside chance of becoming a billion-dollar domestic blockbuster and a two billion dollar movie world wide, so clearly there are plenty of people for whom it worked.

But then I started hearing the same phrase from other people who saw it during the second weekend:

“It was good, but it didn’t quite click.”

At first, I dismissed it as one of those vague reactions people have when they enjoyed a movie without necessarily loving it. But as I talked to more people, the phrase kept coming up.

Some wanted more from Bruce Banner and the Hulk. Others were disappointed that the movie seemed to revisit story arcs and themes we’ve already seen from Marvel.

The more I thought about it, the more I began to agree with them.

Something wasn’t quite clicking.

And after thinking about the movie critically for a few hours, I had a strange thought:

What if Marvel cast the wrong Spider-Man?

Not that Tom Holland is a bad Spider-Man. Far from it. He’s been terrific in the role.

But what if Brand New Day would have worked better with Andrew Garfield?

I’m Not Saying Garfield Should Have Simply Replaced Holland

Obviously, you couldn’t take the exact same movie and simply substitute Andrew Garfield for Tom Holland.

Garfield’s Peter Parker would have changed the movie.

And that’s precisely my point.

The appeal of Brand New Day is that Marvel appears to want to take Spider-Man back toward a more street-level story. After the increasingly cosmic and multiverse-driven Marvel movies—and, yes, after the rather unfortunate experiences of Morbius and Madame Web—I completely understand why fans want that.

I want that too.

But there is a problem.

Tom Holland still feels like “the kid.”

That’s not necessarily a criticism of Holland. It’s one of the things that made him so good as Peter Parker in the first place.

His Spider-Man has always had an energetic, youthful quality. He’s funny. He’s enthusiastic. He’s comfortable around other heroes. He has that slightly awkward quality that makes Peter Parker feel like a teenager who somehow wandered into the Avengers.

But Brand New Day wants something different.

It wants a Spider-Man who has been through the grinder.

A Spider-Man who is alone.

A Spider-Man who has lost people.

A Spider-Man who has grown up.

And that’s where Andrew Garfield suddenly makes a lot of sense.

Garfield’s Spider-Man Already Knows What Loneliness Feels Like

Garfield’s Peter Parker came with a different emotional weight.

His Spider-Man was already somewhat isolated. He carried loss differently. There was a melancholy underneath the jokes.

His Peter didn’t feel like the kid who had just discovered he was Spider-Man.

He felt like someone who had already discovered what being Spider-Man was going to cost him.

That makes the idea of a street-level, lonely, post-trauma Spider-Man much more natural for Garfield.

Again, I’m not saying Garfield would automatically make Brand New Day better.

I’m saying that the character the movie seems to want may be closer to the character Garfield naturally plays.

And that distinction matters.

But Then We Have to Ask the Reverse Question

If Andrew Garfield might be better suited to the Spider-Man Marvel appears to want now, then what kind of Spider-Man movie would have been perfect for Tom Holland?

And that’s when I started laughing.

Because the answer seems almost painfully obvious.

Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends.

Give Tom Holland his own version of the 1970s/1980s animated concept.

Peter Parker.

Firestar.

Iceman.

A little lighter.

A little more fun.

A young Peter surrounded by friends and superheroes, with plenty of banter, ridiculous villains, and the sort of energetic ensemble that Holland does extremely well.

That feels like Tom Holland’s Spider-Man.

And, importantly:

No Punisher.

I’m only half joking.

Holland’s Spider-Man has spent years being the young guy in the room. He works exceptionally well when he’s bouncing off other characters. His chemistry with other superheroes and his ability to play Peter’s enthusiasm are some of his greatest strengths.

Why fight that?

Maybe the Problem Isn’t Tom Holland

This is where my thinking has ended up.

I don’t think the problem with Brand New Day is that Tom Holland suddenly became a bad Spider-Man.

I think Marvel may have run into a casting problem of its own making.

They spent years establishing Holland as their young Spider-Man.

Then they decided they wanted to tell a story about a more mature, isolated, street-level Spider-Man.

Those are not necessarily the same character.

You can age Peter Parker in the script.

You can give him four years of solitude.

You can take away the Avengers and the multiverse.

You can make him more experienced and more independent.

But the audience still sees Tom Holland’s Spider-Man.

And maybe that’s why some people walk out saying:

“It was good. It just didn’t click.”

Perhaps they aren’t rejecting the story.

Perhaps they’re sensing a mismatch between the story Marvel wants to tell and the version of Peter Parker they’ve spent years watching Holland play.

And That’s the Funny Part

If Marvel had asked me beforehand what kind of Spider-Man movie Tom Holland should make, I probably would have said something like:

Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends.

And if they asked me what kind of Spider-Man movie Andrew Garfield should make?

I’d probably say:

Give him the lonely guy wandering through New York at 2 a.m., trying to figure out what the hell he’s doing with his life.

No Avengers.

No multiverse.

No giant cosmic stakes.

Just Spider-Man.

And suddenly the casting makes sense.

Maybe Brand New Day isn’t a bad Spider-Man movie.

Maybe it’s simply a good Spider-Man movie built around a version of Peter Parker that isn’t quite the Peter Parker Tom Holland was best suited to play.

And maybe that’s why, after all the explosions, jokes, cameos, and superhero spectacle, the simplest review from my daughter and several other people may actually be the most revealing:

“It was good. It just didn’t quite click.”


The Odyssey: Why I Believe There Is Very Little Middle Ground

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,

A few weeks ago I wrote that Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey was one of the most difficult films to forecast in years. Since then, trailers have been released, long-range tracking has tightened, and new pieces of the puzzle have emerged.

Instead of making the outlook clearer, they've made it more intriguing.

Early in the year, industry optimism suggested The Odyssey could open near $200 million domestically with an outside chance of reaching $1.5 billion worldwide.

Today, long-range tracking has settled into a much more conservative range of $80–100 million for its domestic opening weekend.

That doesn't mean the film is in trouble.

It does mean expectations have changed.

The Better Comparison

Many analysts continue to compare The Odyssey to Christopher Nolan's Oppenheimer.

I think the better comparison is Ridley Scott's Gladiator.

Like Gladiator, The Odyssey is a large-scale historical epic relying on spectacle, storytelling, and audience enthusiasm rather than an established franchise. Adjusted for inflation, Gladiator's box office would approach $1.3 billion worldwide today—a benchmark The Odyssey is clearly capable of reaching.

Christopher Nolan has earned the benefit of the doubt. His recent track record includes Dunkirk and Oppenheimer, and his name alone makes this one of the year's most anticipated films.

But unlike Oppenheimer, this is a three-hour mythological epic asking audiences to embrace one of the oldest stories ever written.

That makes forecasting considerably more difficult.

Why I See Two Outcomes

I've been asked several times where I think The Odyssey will finish.

My answer hasn't really changed.

I think this film either performs near the top of expectations or near the bottom.

If everything comes together, I could see:

  • $125 million domestic opening

  • Approximately $275 million worldwide opening

  • Around $400 million domestic

  • Roughly $1.2 billion worldwide

If audience enthusiasm is more limited, I could just as easily see:

  • $75–85 million domestic opening

  • Approximately $225 million worldwide opening

  • $300–350 million domestic

  • $800–900 million worldwide

To be clear, $800 million worldwide is an enormous success for almost any movie.

However, with a reported production budget around $250 million and a global marketing campaign likely exceeding $100 million, the margin for error is much smaller than many people realize.

Word of Mouth Will Decide Everything

Unlike many modern blockbusters, I don't believe opening weekend will determine The Odyssey's fate.

Its legs will.

If audiences leave theaters saying:

"You have to see this on the biggest screen possible."

the film could enjoy the kind of sustained run that made Gladiator, Titanic, and The Lord of the Rings cultural phenomena.

If audiences instead say:

"It looked incredible, but it never really connected with me."

then the film could experience a steep second-weekend decline, making a billion-dollar worldwide finish much harder to achieve.

For this movie, word of mouth isn't just important.

It is the entire game.

The Trailer Conversation

One thing that has surprised me is how much discussion has centered on the trailers rather than the filmmaking itself.

Critics have questioned:

  • Modern-looking armor and costumes.

  • Actor accents.

  • Historical authenticity.

  • Whether Nolan's interpretation truly captures Homer's work.

That conversation should sound familiar.

Ridley Scott's Napoleon generated many of the same debates before release. While the two films are very different, it demonstrates how quickly enthusiasm for historical epics can shift when the conversation becomes focused on authenticity instead of storytelling.

The trailers won't determine the movie's success.

But they have undoubtedly shaped the discussion.

The Influencer Question

One development that continues to intrigue me is Universal's decision to cancel influencer screenings.

Many people have argued this simply reflects Christopher Nolan's longstanding dislike of influencer culture.

That may well be true.

However, I keep coming back to the business side of the equation.

This is a film carrying one of the largest budgets of Nolan's career. By most estimates, it needs somewhere between $600 million and $750 million worldwide simply to become profitable.

When the financial stakes are that high, every positive piece of marketing has value.

Influencers alone won't make or break a billion-dollar movie, but they can reinforce momentum, encourage fence-sitters, and help create the feeling that a film is a genuine cultural event.

Viewed in isolation, canceling those screenings isn't particularly meaningful.

Viewed alongside softer tracking, mixed trailer reactions, exceptionally strong IMAX demand but less enthusiasm for standard-format presales, and a shortened theatrical runway, it becomes another interesting data point.

The Spider-Man Problem

Unlike Gladiator, The Odyssey won't have a month to dominate theaters.

Only two weeks after its release comes Spider-Man: Brand New Day.

That means The Odyssey has very little time to establish itself as the movie people simply have to see.

If audiences embrace it immediately, the two films can coexist.

If they don't, losing premium screens and casual moviegoers that quickly could dramatically affect its long-term box office.

The Next Indicators to Watch

Over the next few weeks, I'll be watching four things very closely.

Review embargo timing.

Studios don't choose review embargo dates at random. If reviews are allowed to publish well before opening weekend, it suggests Universal is confident enough to let critical praise become part of its marketing campaign. If reviews are held until Wednesday or Thursday before release, it doesn't automatically mean the film is in trouble, but it does become another data point worth noting.

Standard-format presales.

We already know IMAX demand is extraordinary. The unanswered question is whether that enthusiasm extends beyond Nolan's core audience into traditional multiplex screenings.

The first audience reactions.

The real test begins when paying audiences walk out of the theater. If they're telling friends, "You have to see this," then the box office ceiling rises dramatically.

The second weekend.

This may be the single most important statistic of all. Opening weekend measures anticipation. The second weekend measures audience satisfaction.

Final Thoughts

I'm not predicting failure.

Far from it.

I believe The Odyssey has the potential to become one of the defining films of 2026.

I also believe it's one of the most volatile box office forecasts I've seen in years.

Right now, I don't see a comfortable middle ground.

Either Christopher Nolan has delivered the next great historical epic—one that approaches Gladiator in cultural impact and earns around $1.2 billion worldwide—or the film settles into the $800–900 million range, a remarkable achievement by most standards but one that inevitably raises questions about expectations, marketing strategy, and return on investment.

The next few weeks will tell us a great deal.

The tracking numbers, the review embargo, the presales, and the first audience reactions will each add another piece to the puzzle.

And when opening weekend finally arrives, the number that interests me most won't be Friday night's gross.

It will be what audiences are saying as they walk out of the theater on Saturday.

Being asked about Movies Again.

Posted by Jeff Labels:

Recently I've been asked about several films and what I think about them.

That always makes me smile because it reminds me of a different chapter in my life.

Back in the early days of the internet, I maintained a movie review blog. I reviewed films, analyzed box office performance, tracked DVD sales, and spent an unhealthy amount of time trying to understand why some movies succeeded while others failed.

Eventually I built a box office prediction model that incorporated roughly a dozen factors. For genres I followed closely, the results were surprisingly accurate. For genres I didn't particularly care about, the model's performance could generously be described as "aspirational."

The important thing is that I learned something.

Movies are both art and business.

Many critics focus exclusively on the art.

Many studio executives focus exclusively on the business.

The reality is that success usually requires both.

That perspective colors how I look at movies even today.

So when people ask me what I think about a film, my answer is rarely just whether I liked it. I tend to think about audience expectations, marketing, release windows, competition, and how the film was constructed.

Three recent conversations illustrate exactly what I mean.

The Mandalorian and Grogu Problem

The first film people asked me about was The Mandalorian and Grogu.

The question was simple:

Why didn't it connect with audiences?

There are several answers.

First, there is a portion of the audience that feels personally burned by previous Lucasfilm projects. Whether those feelings are justified or not doesn't really matter. Some viewers have simply disengaged from the franchise and were never likely to buy a ticket.

Second, the economics of movie-going have changed.

Going to a theater today is expensive.

Most people own large televisions. Many have decent sound systems. Streaming services have conditioned audiences to wait.

A decade ago a theatrical release felt like an event.

Today many viewers simply ask:

"Will this be worth seeing now, or can I watch it on Disney+ in a few months?"

That question alone has changed the industry.

But I don't think either of those issues is the biggest problem.

The biggest issue is structural.

The Mandalorian is a television series.

Its strengths are television strengths.

The series thrives on character moments, episodic adventures, side stories, and gradual development. It gives characters time to breathe.

The movie felt like multiple episodes compressed into a little over two hours.

Some people I've talked to felt it was three episodes.

Others thought it felt like five.

My estimate is somewhere around four.

Regardless of the exact number, the effect is the same.

The connective tissue gets removed.

Character development gets compressed.

Background information disappears.

The quieter moments that make audiences care about characters are shortened or eliminated.

The result is a film that feels uneven.

Not because the individual scenes are bad, but because it was originally designed to function as serialized storytelling.

The irony is that the film's greatest weakness may be the very thing that made the television series successful.

The Odyssey: Billion-Dollar Success or Expensive Disappointment?

The second film people keep asking me about is Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey.

The first question is always:

"What do you think of it?"

The second question is usually:

"Will it make a billion dollars?"

Let's start with the movie itself.

As a history major who has read far too many books on the Bronze Age, I was put off by the trailers.

What I saw didn't feel much like the Bronze Age.

That doesn't automatically mean the movie will be bad.

Historical authenticity and cinematic storytelling are often different goals.

Still, my initial reaction was concern.

Hollywood has a long history of historical epics where the filmmakers decide they don't particularly like the appearance of the period they're depicting.

The result is often a movie that looks more like a modern interpretation of history than history itself.

When I watched the trailer, I didn't think "Homer."

I thought "Christopher Nolan's version of Homer."

That may prove to be a masterpiece.

It may prove to be a mistake.

We'll find out soon enough.

As for the box office, I think this is one of the easiest films to predict and one of the hardest films to predict simultaneously.

My take is simple.

There is no middle ground.

I don't see this film quietly making $950 million.

I don't see it barely crossing a billion.

Instead, I think we're looking at one of two outcomes.

Either it finishes in the $750-900 million range and is viewed as a disappointment relative to expectations.

Or it explodes into the $1.2-1.4 billion range and becomes one of the biggest hits of the decade.

Why?

Christopher Nolan.

After Oppenheimer, Nolan is one of the few directors whose name alone sells tickets.

The question isn't whether Nolan's fans will show up.

They already have.

What concerns me is that large-format screenings are selling well while standard screenings appear much softer.

That suggests the core Nolan audience has bought tickets.

The question is whether everyone else follows.

The film also has limited time to establish itself before Spider-Man: Brand New Day begins consuming screens and premium formats.

The opening weeks will determine everything.

The Collision Course: Avengers vs. Dune

The third conversation is actually two films.

Avengers: Doomsday and Dune 3.

Why discuss them together?

Because they are currently scheduled to release on the same day.

That alone makes this one of the most fascinating box office battles in years.

Even more interesting is how the studios appear to have divided the battlefield.

Warner Bros. has secured the IMAX screens for Dune 3.

Disney has secured virtually everything else for Avengers: Doomsday.

Both studios are playing to their strengths.

Warner Bros. is betting that audiences want to experience Dune in premium formats.

Disney is betting that Marvel wins through scale.

If both films remain on the same date, I think the opening weekend is relatively straightforward.

Avengers: Doomsday is likely looking at an opening north of $200 million domestically.

Possibly much higher.

Dune 3 probably lands in the $50-60 million range.

At first glance that looks like a blowout.

I don't think it is.

The two franchises behave differently.

Marvel films tend to be front-loaded.

They generate enormous opening weekends.

The Dune films rely more heavily on premium-format sales, critical reception, and audience word of mouth.

The real battle won't be opening weekend.

It will be the weeks that follow.

Can Dune 3 dominate premium formats long enough to build momentum?

Can Avengers: Doomsday reestablish Marvel as appointment viewing?

Both films have enormous stakes.

For Warner Bros., Dune 3 is prestige filmmaking with potential Oscar implications.

For Disney, Avengers: Doomsday may be the most important Marvel film since Endgame.

Neither studio wants to blink.

Yet history tells us studios are brave until the spreadsheets tell them not to be.

Would I be shocked if one moved?

Not at all.

Would I be surprised if both held their ground?

Not really.

There is simply too much at stake for either company.

Why I Still Enjoy Talking About Movies

The funny thing about these conversations is that they remind me why I enjoyed reviewing movies all those years ago.

The movies themselves are interesting.

The audience is fascinating.

The business can be downright unpredictable.

Most people ask whether a movie will be good.

I find myself asking different questions.

Who is the audience?

What are they expecting?

What experience are they paying for?

And perhaps most importantly:

Does the movie understand what its audience wants?

Because more often than not, that answer determines the box office long before the first ticket is sold.

Galaxy Quest - Honest Trailer

Posted by Jeff Labels: ,


X-Men and the MCU - Commentary

Posted by Jeff Labels: , , , ,

Fox's second to the last X-Men film is about to hit theaters and Disney is about to get stuck between a Rock and Hard place with a decision it has to make concerning the X-Men films.   

Dark Phoenix was not expected to be very good and thanks to throwing money at the film it became a lot more expensive than it was originally planned.    Many expected the film to end the X-Men universe from Fox with a whimper.

The film is currently sitting at a 25% on rottentomatoes.com, it is not very good. I hear you all saying it.   Read the reviews.   Many reviewers were simply looking for a comic book movie to take out their displeasure with comic book movies on.   They didn't dare attack the MCU and the DCEU and Hellboy aren't big enough targets.  The reviewers who actually like comic books or comic book films actually liked or at least didn't dislike the film.  Based upon Metacritic.com the average score for those that liked the film, the top 55% was ~65 out of 100.   The bottom 44% is ~28 out of 100.  That's a wide gulf of difference of opinion.    In looking at the critic scores not put into metacritic yet I think there is a good possibility the gulf grows.

Dark Phoenix is not a good movie, but it isn't a bad movie and nowhere near as bad as it rottentomatoes.com score either.   The real score will be better measured by cinemascore or other similar metric.  Do the people that see the movie like the movie?    Does Dark Phoenix get positive word of mouth?

This is where Disney and Marvel Studios run into their conundrum.    Dark Phoenix was expected to lose money, lots of it.  Giving Disney the easy answer in ending the X-Men Universe.    Problem is it might end up making money and end up in the black.   As one analyst suggested it is not improbable that the film makes $50 to $100 Million in profit.

How does it get into the black?
$150 domestic and $450 overseas or $125 domestic and $525 foreign earns $300 in revenues on a $200 Million dollar film (plus marketing).   That's about $50 in the black.  

This isn't the first time that the X-Men were on the chopping block. 

So what happens if Dark Phoenix ends in the black with a solid cinemascore from fans?

Well it is complicated.

The answer may lie with a few statements made by past directors of the X-Men franchise not named Bryan Singer.   Simon Kinberg recently spoke about how professional and organized Marvel Studios are in comparison to 20th Century Fox.    How things like schedules and budgets and special effects and oversight are better with Marvel Studios.  Gavin Hood, Brett Ratner, and Matthew Vaughn have been critical to the lack of support and changes made, often without their knowledge, by 20th Century Fox.   James Mangold hasn't openly criticized 20th Century Fox, but he suggested that The Wolverine was held back by some 20th Century Fox issues.                 

When Disney finally decides to do something with the X-Men they have three very different options to choose from.

1) A Hard reboot and Merge with the Marvel Cinematic Universe
2) A Soft Reboot and a Merge with the Marvel Cinematic Universe
3) A Soft Reboot and a separate X-Men Universe.  

Most fans are in favor of option 1.   It is all over the fan pages and forums.   And before I saw Dark Phoenix I was in that spot.

Option 3 has been pitched to Bob Iger, CEO of Disney, but he has publicly stated that Disney will be happy to put X-Men under Marvel Studios.

Option 2 seemed ridiculous two days-ago.   If Marvel Studios will be the production company, than a Hard Reboot, cut from 20th Century Fox X-Men seemed all but assured.


At the moment I think Option 1 is still the most likely solution, but neither Option 2 nor Option 3 should be removed completely from the table, yet.
The bigger the box office the more likely they movie down the list.   If Dark Phoenix post $50 to $100 Million in profit option 2 becomes a stronger choice and if for some reason the movie brings in $200 Million plus in profit (Talking about a $750 world wide take) option 3 comes into play.

Me personally I think option 2 is the good choice, but there is no best choice.  

Bob Iger what are you going to do?

Dark Phoenix - Review

Posted by Jeff Labels: , ,


Dark Phoenix is not a good movie, but it is not a bad movie either.   It is stuck in that nebulous realm of being simply an okay movie.   I would also add that if you are a fan of the X-Men comics, you actually might like the movie.


The script is a big problem for this film.  The best way to think of the script is to look at 8 episode series for The Runaways paired down to 2 hours and shown on a big screen.  It is not a script for a big budget movie, the scope is too small and you are expected to know exactly what happened  in the missing six hours of the film that you don't see.

The script is not true to the source material, changes are made simply for the sake of changes.   As a fan of the X-Men comics I found this frustration difficult to contain while I watched the film.  I am sure the poor guy sitting next to me was exacerbated with me as I sighed and probably asked "Why?" out loud more than once.  

The script wastes the talents of multiple actors through out the film.    The film has a triumvirate of actors at the core with Jennifer Lawrence (Raven Darkholm/Mystique), James McAvoy (Charles Xavier) and Michael Fassbender (Erik Lensherr/Magento) that is interlaced with Sophie Turner's character (Jean Grey).     You can easily question why the next six core X-Men are in the film, they are given little to no screen time and beyond one or two moments they are not given a chance to showcase their talents or their mutant powers. 

Mystique is presented as a caring and guiding teacher, Charles Xavier is a villain and Magneto is not prepared for what comes.   I was dumb founded.     There are a couple of scenes that are hard to watch.

I still have no idea why Jessica Chastain was in the film, other than someone at 20th Century Fox said there needed to be a main villain, named Vuk.    She is not realistically given anything to do nor do you believe she is a great villain, but she is there to unite the X-Men. 

The special effects are hit and miss.   While those involving Jean Grey and a few around other characters are okay, many look like they belong in a 1980's era TV show.   You just want Ryan Reynolds to show up as Deadpool and give a Mystery Science Theater 3000 commentary on more than one scene.  

The second act is a complete mess.   Issues with the characters, scripts, poor acting, bad direction, and literally it doesn't seem to properly connect with the first or third act. 

Sophie Turner is very good as Jean Grey.  To put it mildly it is disappointing she will most likely not take up the mantle of Jean Grey in the MCU, because she is one bad ass woman you don't want to mess with.

There are a many good lines in the movie.   For a script that is so bad with it's swings and missed it hits the nail on the head solidly a good dozen times.    

Hans Zimmer's score is exceptional; with over 200 composer credits this is easily within his top five  and maybe even his best work.     If the movie was slightly better I would say this is Oscar worthy, as it is it still might be.