I didn't watch The Uprising when it was in theaters in September. It was a movie I wanted to see, but real life interrupted my movie-viewing plans. Again.
Having not seen the movie, I was caught off guard when a friend asked me, "Why does The Uprising blow chunks?"
I finally watched it over the weekend on Peacock. I don't think the movie blows chunks, but it isn't very good either. So, the obvious question is: Why?
As a history major, people sometimes assume I know the background of whatever historical epic they're discussing and understand exactly what's supposed to be going on. Unfortunately, the Peasants' Revolt of 1381 is an era of English history I know relatively little about. I can tell you it happened in 1381, but beyond that, you're not going to get much from me without opening a book.
That said, after watching the movie, I did a little reading. And that made me even more disappointed with what the filmmakers produced.
In many ways, The Uprising was set up for success. It has a strong cast, an abundance of extras, and a historical period that hasn't been overproduced in film and television. The Peasants' Revolt is a fascinating subject, and its themes of economic inequality, political power, taxation, and social unrest certainly resonate with contemporary audiences.
The filmmakers had plenty to work with.
Unfortunately, being set up for success doesn't mean you can execute the project successfully. And that's what happens here.
You can have a great cast, but if the story is incomplete, the cinematography is distracting, and the sound is uninspired, you have a problem. A movie needs more than recognizable actors and a collection of impressive-looking battle scenes.
The Story That Wasn't Told
The biggest problem with The Uprising is the story itself.
It isn't complete. More importantly, it doesn't seem to know whether it wants to tell the actual historical story or create a new mythology around it. It attempts to blend the two and doesn't do either particularly well.
The Peasants' Revolt wasn't simply a spontaneous uprising of impoverished people who decided they had enough of the ruling class.
England was still recovering from the Black Death. The enormous loss of life had changed the labor market, and ordinary workers were in a position to demand better wages and conditions. The government and landowners responded with restrictions on wages and workers' freedom to move. Then came the poll taxes, including the particularly unpopular tax of 1381.
There was a great deal going on beneath the surface.
And then there was the king.
Richard II was only fourteen years old when the revolt occurred. Think about that for a moment. A teenage king suddenly confronted with an enormous rebellion, surrounded by powerful advisers, and expected to maintain control of a kingdom experiencing serious social and economic upheaval.
That's a story.
The rebels weren't necessarily trying to abolish the monarchy. Many believed the king was being misled by corrupt advisers and officials. They wanted their grievances heard, and some believed Richard himself might be sympathetic to their cause.
Why isn't more of this explored?
The film needed someone to sit down with the script and ask a fairly simple question: Why are these characters doing what they're doing?
What motivates them? What do they want? What are they afraid of? What are they willing to sacrifice?
Too often, the characters simply do things because the screenplay requires them to. Their motivations are either poorly explained or never developed. I found myself wondering why certain characters made particular decisions, and a little historical reading afterward only made me wonder why the filmmakers hadn't included some of that background.
The actual history offers plenty of dramatic possibilities. You shouldn't have to invent motivations for historical figures when their real circumstances are already interesting.
The Robin Hood Problem
The other issue is the film's apparent desire to connect the events of 1381 with the Robin Hood legend.
I understand the temptation. Robin Hood is a familiar figure, and the idea of connecting a popular legend to an actual historical rebellion probably sounds attractive to a screenwriter.
But there is a problem.
The Robin Hood tradition is generally associated with an earlier period, often the reign of Richard I, and references to Robin Hood existed before the Peasants' Revolt.
In other words, the filmmakers are trying to create an origin story for a legend that was already circulating.
Why?
The events of 1381 don't need Robin Hood to make them interesting. The actual revolt, its leaders, the young king, and the eventual suppression of the rebellion provide more than enough material.
This is where the movie seems caught between history and mythology. It wants the credibility of a historical epic but also wants to create a heroic legend. The two approaches don't necessarily have to conflict, but the filmmakers never quite make them work together.
The Shaky Camera
The next disturbing problem is the extensive use of the shaky-handheld-camera technique.
If you want to see a good execution of this method, watch Saving Private Ryan. If you want to see a bad execution, The Uprising is a perfect choice.
Handheld cinematography can be extremely effective. It can put the audience in the middle of a battle, create confusion, and make events feel immediate and chaotic.
But there is a time and place for it.
Why are we using a shaky camera during scenes involving the king's council? What exactly are the filmmakers trying to accomplish other than giving a portion of the audience motion sickness?
A technique that works in a battle scene doesn't automatically work in a conversation. Cinematography should serve the story, not become a distraction from it.
There are moments when I wanted the camera to simply stop moving so I could concentrate on what the characters were saying.
That's not a good sign.
Everything Is Dull and Dirty
Then there is the overall appearance of the movie.
Everything is dull and dirty. The landscapes, the costumes, the people, and the characters all seem to exist in a world without much color.
Apparently, historical realism means everything has to be brown, gray, muddy, and miserable.
As a historian, I can tell you that grass was still green and the sky was still blue in 1381. I don't need a history book to tell me that.
Medieval people wore colored clothing. They dyed fabrics, decorated their homes, maintained gardens, and lived in a world that wasn't permanently covered by a gray filter.
Yes, life could be difficult. Yes, there was poverty, disease, and plenty of mud. But the fourteenth century wasn't a monochromatic wasteland.
There is a difference between gritty and realistic.
A muted color palette can be an effective artistic choice, but when everything is muted, the audience loses visual contrast. Eventually, everything starts to look the same.
The filmmakers seem to have confused making a movie look miserable with making it historically authentic.
The Sound Doesn't Help
The sound is another disappointment.
A historical epic needs to create an atmosphere. The sounds of crowds, horses, weapons, and the surrounding environment should help bring the audience into the period.
Instead, the sound design feels rather uninspired. There isn't enough to make the world feel alive, and the overall presentation lacks the impact that a film of this scale should deliver.
It's another example of a production that has the pieces but doesn't seem to know how to put them together.
A Much Better Movie Was Sitting There Waiting to Be Made
What frustrates me most about The Uprising is that the filmmakers had such an interesting historical event available to them.
The Peasants' Revolt of 1381 offers a story about economic change, social class, political power, corruption, and a fourteen-year-old king trying to maintain control of his kingdom.
It is a story about people who believed the system was working against them and who decided to do something about it. It is also a story about how quickly a rebellion can turn into something its original participants may not have intended.
The revolt ultimately failed. Wat Tyler was killed, the king reasserted royal authority, and the government pursued those involved in the rebellion.
There is plenty of drama in that history. There are no shortages of heroes, villains, conflicting motivations, or tragic consequences.
You don't need to manufacture a legend to make it compelling.
And that's really my problem with the movie.
It had a strong cast, an interesting historical setting, plenty of extras, and a subject that could have made for an excellent historical epic. But the screenplay never fully develops its characters or their motivations. The cinematography becomes distracting, the visual presentation is unnecessarily dull, and the sound does little to enhance the experience.
I don't think The Uprising blows chunks.
But it certainly doesn't live up to the opportunity it was given.
Sometimes the most frustrating movies aren't the ones with terrible ideas. They're the ones where you can see the good movie that could have been made, sitting just beneath the surface of the one you actually watched.

0 comments:
Post a Comment